Comics · Queer

A to Z: Pied Piper (Hartley Rathaway)

Pied Piper

Brace yourselves. I love a lot of the characters on this list, and I love even more characters who AREN’T on this list… But Pied Piper is my FAVORITE OF THEM ALL. I’ve read him in very few stories, and I’m not sure I can satisfactorily explain why he is my favorite above all others, but I shall certainly try.

Pied Piper, aka Hartley Rathaway, is a member of the Flash’s excellent rogue’s gallery. That’s nerd-talk for “list of villains,” but in this case, Piper is associated with a group of Flash villains actually called The Rogues, since his creation in 1959. He was pretty much one of those “obsession + too much time on his hands + fell in with the wrong crowd” villains. He was born deaf in a wealthy family and gained the ability to hear through experimental implants, but remained obsessed with sound. He developed ways to weaponize sound, mostly through hypnotic vibrations, although he could also cause death.

Despite being permanently linked to the Rogues, however, he’s one of the few villains to actually reform and stay reformed, transforming into a hero. Barely even an anti-hero, in fact. (And yes, he’s one of the few gay villains and one of the few villains to “go straight.” The irony escapes no one.) He realizes he can use his wealth and skills to help people. Kind of like Batman, only not so crazy. He even becomes close friends with the Flash. He still gets around as Pied Piper, of course… And his ability to pretend he’s a villain again has served him well.

So that’s why I love Hartley. He seems like a simple throwaway villain idea, and was probably conceived as such, but he’s developed into someone who’s so much more interesting than that. He has an air of sweetness that sometimes obscures how intelligent and hardline he can really be. Like the Flash’s other villains, he often rests somewhere between “superhero/supervillain” and “everyday man.” That’s a compelling place to be, because it’s the kind of extraordinary we can actually reach ourselves.

Recommended Reading:

  • Coming-out issue: The Flash #53 from 1991. It’s super cute and low-key, since he and Flash were friends at this point. It takes Flash a little while to get used to the idea, but it doesn’t strain the friendship. Adorbs and available on Comixology.
  • Best: Countdown to Final Crisis. I ship him with Trickster so hard YOU DON’T EVEN KNOW. This is also the best place to get a full Piper story instead of just an appearance, although the series itself is a little confusing.
    • Countdown to Final Crisis Vol. 1 (various authors, pub. 2008, ISBN 978-1401217891)
    • Countdown to Final Crisis Vol. 2 (ISBN 978-1401218249)
    • Countdown to Final Crisis Vol. 3 (ISBN 978-1401219116)
    • Countdown to Final Crisis Vol. 4 (ISBN 978-1401219123)
    • I guess you’ll want to read Final Crisis here, but don’t say I sent you. Did not like, and does not have Piper. You’d probably be LESS confused if you skip it, anyway. By Grant Morrison, ISBN 978-1401245177 for the paperback.
    • Final Crisis: Rogues’ Revenge by Geoff Johns (ISBN 978-1401223342). Piper’s back in this one!
  • New 52: Hartley has appeared in Flash as an orchestra conductor dating one of the police officers. So far, and unsurprisingly, he’s my favorite part of that series but doesn’t get to do very much. Vol. 1 is called Move Forward. 
  • On TV: Hartley appears in the Flash TV series, still gay and still deaf with hearing implants, although they chose to put him in a science accident rather than be born with a disability. I haven’t seen the show yet, but I have high hopes!

If there is a Sunday Post tomorrow, it’ll be late in the evening. Time for a day off, lovelies, and I’ve got plans for it! 😉

20 thoughts on “A to Z: Pied Piper (Hartley Rathaway)

  1. (Ironically watching Arrow right now) I only know him from the Flash TV show, and he was fascinating – the villain so far who’s done the best against Team Flash. And he hints at knowing way more than he has revealed so far – meaning I really hope that he comes back in the show soon 😀 And the door is totally open for him eventually becoming good instead of bad… or to join the Rogues! Or, ya know, both!

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Great post! I’m really enjoying your A-Z posts! Is the character modelled on the Pied Piper of folklore/fairy tale? Who/what does he lead?


    1. Thanks! He is inspired by the Pied Piper of Hamlin, yes! It’s a loose interpretation — he doesn’t have any particular power over children or rats or anything like that, but he can hypnotize/control people through sound vibrations.


  3. I love it when that happens – when a character seems destined to be inconsequential in the grand scheme of things and completely turns the writers/readers around! I also love characters who conquer their demons, so he’s a win win 🙂

    Liked by 1 person

        1. Probably a confusing sentence — he actually came out after becoming a hero. I was just referring to the expression “going straight,” as in a criminal ceasing to be a criminal. He makes some jokes about it. 🙂

          Liked by 1 person

  4. The Flash TV show is utterly adorable! You should watch it. Granted, I never read the Flash comics, so I don’t have a base for comparison. But I do love the show. So much better than Arrow right now.

    @TarkabarkaHolgy from
    Multicolored Diary – Epics from A to Z
    MopDog – 26 Ways to Die in Medieval Hungary

    Liked by 1 person

      1. Arrow season 3 is a hot mess, with a textbook example of handling relationships badly. I only watch it now because it intersects with the Flash so often…


          1. Yeah 😛 It has some new characters that redeem if, but from what I hear they will spin off soon into a separate show…

            Liked by 1 person


Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s